How Legal Contracts Trap Timeshare Owners for Life
Timeshare is a complicated topic. Often presented and sold as an easy and secure way to plan future vacations. Buyers are shown attractive resorts, promised convenience, and encouraged to focus on the enjoyment ahead rather than the paperwork in front of them. In many cases, the legal contract is treated as a formality rather than a binding agreement with long term consequences. Once signed, however, that contract can lock owners into ongoing financial obligations and legal responsibilities that are far more difficult to exit than they were led to believe.
A recent matter in Pennsylvania shows how misleading sales representations and pressure to sign can place consumers into long term timeshare obligations they never intended to accept. In Lehigh County, a couple who had owned a timeshare for more than thirty years said they were told their only way out was to convert their ownership into points and then sell those points back to the timeshare developer. After paying to convert, they later discovered that the developer’s buyback program had ended years earlier. It took months of dispute and escalation before the couple was ultimately refunded and released from the agreement.
As timeshare contracts grow more complex and obligations stretch further into the future, consumers must understand what they are being asked to sign. Without careful review and clear documentation, buyers can easily become trapped by sales tactics that do not align with the legal reality of the contract.
High Pressure Timeshare Sales Presentations
One of the most common timeshare tactics is the high-pressure sales environment. Prospective buyers are invited to an appealing resort stay, often with promises of free or discounted nights, meals, or gifts. Once there, the timeshare presentation begins. These sales presentations can last for hours. Sales representatives often use a series of tactics to wear down resistance. New staff take over at different points in the conversation to reset objections and build a sense of momentum. The sales pacing is deliberate. By the time the buyer gets to the contract, they are less focused on reading the details and more focused on finishing the process. The salesperson might say the deal requires a decision now, that this offer expires soon, or that demand is high. These statements are designed to keep buyers from stepping away to think more clearly or consult outside legal advisors.
Verbal Promises That Don’t Hold Up
Another major issue is the reliance on verbal assurances. Sales staff at resorts often make verbal promises about how easy it is to resell a timeshare, how flexible the contract is, or how a future buyback program will work.
In the Lehnerts’ case, they were told that after converting their deeded timeshare to points they could sell the points back to the developer, recouping the $30,000 cost of exiting the contract. That promise was written down informally during the sales conversation, but it was never included in the formal contract. When the timeshare developer no longer offered point buybacks, the Lehnerts had no written proof of the promise and were initially stuck with the result. Because the contract did not guarantee the buyback, the company felt it could legally deny the representation.
Long Term and Indefinite Obligations
A key piece of advice from experts in consumer protection is to remember that timeshares are often long lasting or indefinite commitments.
Kevin Brasler, executive editor of nonprofit Consumers’ Checkbook, shared with CBS news that the Lehnerts’ case is a reminder to get everything in writing and be cautious with timeshare agreements, which often last indefinitely.
“The thing with timeshares is you’re committing to having a vacation with a certain company forever,” Brasler said. “It’s better not to marry yourself to one company for anything.”
This point is critical. Many contracts do not include automatic expiration dates. Owners must continue paying annual maintenance fees, special assessments, and other charges for as long as they own the timeshare. Even if they stop using it, the financial obligation can continue.
Complex Structures and Limited Flexibility
Timeshare vacation plans come in many forms. Some are deeded weeks at a specific resort. Others, like points-based vacation clubs, allow owners to use points to reserve stays at many different resorts. While points can seem more flexible, the rules governing points usage are complex. Availability of desired dates and locations often requires planning more than a year in advance. When demand is high, points may not always secure stays in peak seasons.
In some vacation programs, the number of points required to book a stay can increase over time. As a result, owners may need more points to reserve the same or similar vacations they once enjoyed. To make up the difference, members are often encouraged to purchase additional points at extra cost, not to improve their experience, but simply to secure a vacation they can actually book.
Timeshare Costs That Increase Over Time
Another risk many timeshare buyers fail to consider before signing is the cost trajectory over time. Annual timeshare maintenance fees increases are routine. But timeshare associations can also levy special assessments for repairs, renovations, or improvements. These fees can rise significantly over time.
Even when owners use their timeshare only sporadically, they remain responsible for these costs. Vacation club members who stop using their points-based timeshare can find themselves paying hundreds or thousands of dollars each year for something they rarely enjoy.
Owner Upgrades and Additional Offers
Sales tactics do not stop once a contract is signed. Owners are frequently invited back for presentations that look like “owner updates” or social events. In reality, these sessions are often new sales pitches to upgrade the contract.
Upgrades may promise more flexibility, larger units, or access to better resort weeks. What is often left unsaid is that upgrades come with additional financial obligations and often reset cancellation windows or add new long-term commitments. Over time these upsell presentations can generate tens of thousands more in costs for owners who hoped upgrades would solve problems instead of creating new ones.
Reading the Timeshare Contract Carefully
Because of how timeshare contracts are structured, reading every legal detail is essential, especially given how legal contracts can trap timeshare owners for life. Buyers should never rely on verbal assurances, and any promise made by a sales representative must be clearly included in the written contract.
Timeshare agreements often contain detailed language about fees, cancellation rights, transfer restrictions, and the actual rights owners have under the plan. Many contracts also include provisions that make exiting the agreement extremely difficult or expensive once it is signed. Removing the contract from the sales environment, reviewing it carefully, and having a timeshare lawyer or trusted advisor examine the terms before signing can help consumers avoid long term legal and financial problems.
Protecting Yourself Before You Sign a Timeshare Contract
Timeshares may work well for some people, but only when buyers enter with full understanding and realistic expectations. Before agreeing to anything:
- Demand all promises be written into the contract.
- Take the contract home or to a trusted advisor before signing.
- Understand the annual fees and potential assessments.
- Ask about cancellation rights and the exact procedures for a timeshare exit.
- Avoid making decisions under extreme pressure.
Being informed and cautious can help consumers avoid the long-term financial risks and disappointments that too many timeshare owners face.
______________________________________________________________________
Disclosure: This article is for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. You should consult a qualified timeshare attorney for advice specific to your situation.
Led by timeshare attorneys J. Andrew Meyer and Michael D. Finn with over 75 years of combined legal experience. The Finn Law Group is a national consumer protection firm that specializes in Timeshare Law. If you feel you need the services of a timeshare attorney, contact our law firm today at 855-FINN-LAW. Want to learn more about timeshare related issues? Follow us on X, formally Twitter.
